Skip to main content

The Canes' continued interest in Erik Karlsson presents more questions than answers

The Canes missed out on the star defenseman in 2023 before a division foe picked him up, but even with a second chance to nab him, should they pull the trigger?
ByBen Huffman
Mar 22, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Erik Karlsson (65) moves the puck against Carolina Hurricanes left wing Nikolaj Ehlers (27) during the first period at PPG Paints Arena. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images
Mar 22, 2026; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Erik Karlsson (65) moves the puck against Carolina Hurricanes left wing Nikolaj Ehlers (27) during the first period at PPG Paints Arena. Mandatory Credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Carolina Hurricanes haven't been afraid to go after every big fish on the market over the last several years. Sometimes, their pursuits pay off. Other times, they're outbid by someone else. Of course, there's always the chance that their interest is overblown, but it makes for interesting speculation throughout the season.

Last week, the rumor mill began to swirl when The Athletic's Pierre LeBrun speculated that the Hurricanes might take a run at star defenseman Erik Karlsson, should the Penguins look to trade him. That avenue could be open by March, especially with how the Penguins' season has started. Pittsburgh is seventh in the division, as of Monday, and things aren't trending positively.

However, Karlsson hasn't shown any signs of slowing down. Turning 37 in May, Karlsson leads the Penguins with 16 assists and 19 points, including a team-high eight points on the power play. He hasn't lost a step skating, and he's playing big minutes (23:38), averaging over 3:30 more per contest than his teammates.

Set to be a free agent at the end of the season, the Penguins could look to get something for Karlsson before or at the trade deadline. While he holds a No-Movement Clause, Penguins General Manager Kyle Dubas has been open about his talks with Karlsson's camp and about finding something that would benefit both parties, should that moment come.

Karlsson has done just about everything during his career. He's a three-time Norris Trophy winner, to go with two second-place finishes. He was the first defenseman in over 30 years to record 100 points, hitting 101 in 2022-23. The only big thing left for him to achieve is a Stanley Cup victory, having lost in the conference finals twice. If he's chasing a Cup, Carolina might be the perfect spot.

The fits exists, but there's no clear path for the Canes to acquire Karlsson

This would not be the first time that the Hurricanes made a run for Karlsson. In 2023, they showed serious interest in bringing him over from the Sharks before the Penguins landed him in a massive three-team deal with Montreal. It was another failed pursuit by the Canes, and while they would've loved to get that done, it probably worked out for the best.

I don't doubt that they'll be interested in trying to get something done, should Karlsson become available in the future. However, I can't help but ask myself a million questions about how the team would make that work. There are so many moving pieces involved in a potential Karlsson trade, beginning with how their defense aligns.

After losing Mike Reilly to waivers, this is how the Hurricanes' defense is currently constructed:

LD

RD

Jaccob Slavin

Jalen Chatfield

K'Andre Miller

Sean Walker

Shayne Gostisbehere (PP1)

Alexander Nikishin (PP2)

Juuso Valimaki

It's also important to note that Gostisbehere, Chatfield, and Valimaki will all be unrestricted free agents at the end of the season, while Nikishin will be a restricted free agent and is two years away from being UFA-eligible. That could be of some importance because I don't think that the Hurricanes can get this done without trading one of them. Otherwise, what would the point be?

While I think Nikishin would fit well with the Penguins, it wouldn't be smart to trade him in this situation. Karlsson would purely be a rental for a playoff run. At most, he extends for a year or two. There's no way that the Canes would trade a pending RFA defenseman within the division in this scenario. The Penguins would love to do that, especially with how desperately they need to get younger.

If the Hurricanes are going to make this trade, I think trading Gostisbehere makes the "most sense", and I use that in the loosest terms possible. I said as much last August when talking about this exact topic. He's a cheaper option for Pittsburgh, will demand less on his next deal, and does a lot of the same things as Karlsson, while being a little more reliable on the defensive end.

If Gostisbehere is moved to make room for Karlsson, there isn't a planet where Karlsson is on the third pair with Alexander Nikishin. That would be a defensive-zone nightmare. Instead, this is how I think the defense would look:

LD

RD

Jaccob Slavin

Erik Karlsson (PP1)

K'Andre Miller

Sean Walker

Alexander Nikishin (PP2)

Jalen Chatfield

Juuso Valimaki

Of course, Karlsson for Gostisbehere straight up wouldn't get it done. The Canes have picks and prospects to complete a deal, regardless of Pittsburgh's asking price, which I'm sure would be high. That's the other reason I'm not really convinced that the Hurricanes will go after Karlsson. The Canes aren't giving up a haul for a rental. It really needs to be worth it.

The landscape will change between now and March's trade deadline. While the Canes don't have a major need for a defenseman now, that might not be the case in the next few months. Hockey changes in the blink of an eye. I don't think this move will happen without a major change to the status quo in Raleigh. Then again, crazier things have happened.

Add us as a preferred source on Google