2004: Andrew Ladd (LW) 4th Overall 1001GP 256G 294A 615 PIM
This is a tough pick to judge because while Ladd had a fantastic NHL career, he did pretty much all of it after his time with the Carolina Hurricanes. He did play some meaningful minutes on the 2006 cup-winning squad but was traded for Tuomo Ruutu one year later. Ruutu was an important player for the 2009 ECF team but we missed out on having a player with Ladd’s toughness and leadership throughout his career. Other first-round picks could have been All-Stars Blake Wheeler (5th Overall) and Mike Green (29th Overall), goalies Devan Dubnyk (14th Overall) and Corey Schnieder (26th Overall), or the talented Alex Radulov (15th Overall)